Ultimate Cream of Tomato Soup

October 2024

Recipe from Cook's Illustrated, November 1999

I have made tomato soup using several different recipes and have written about some of them here.  Unfortunately it is not practical to compare the several recipes and my memory is not good enough to do a comparison that is not side-by-side. But I can try the recipe and write about the results so I have something to go by the next time I want to make, in this case, tomato soup.

I made just two changes to the ingredients, omitting both the brandy and the cayenne pepper. The key ingredient is two cans of whole tomatoes packed in juice. The tomatoes were drained, retaining the juice, and seeded. They were sprinkled with brown sugar and roasted to bring out their flavor. While the tomatoes roasted and cooled, the remaining ingredients were prepared. Then, diced shallots, tomato paste, and allspice were cooked in a large saucepan. Flour was added and cooked. Chicken stock, reserved tomato juice, and roasted tomatoes were stirred in and simmered to blend flavors. The mixture was strained and the solids were blended with 1 cup of the liquids until smooth. The pureed mixture, strained liquids, and cream were stirred together in a cleaned saucepan and cooked over low heat. Salt was added to finish the dish. Total time was 1 hour, 40 minutes.

We liked the soup and were impressed with its sweet and strong tomato flavor. The texture was just right for tomato soup. Diane commented that it was better than recipes that used bread as a thickener. The recipe made enough soup for 3-4 dinners for two.