February 2026
Recipe from Cook's Illustrated, January 2026
I’m almost always up for trying a simple chicken recipe, and this one fits the bill—easy enough for a weeknight and paired with a flavorful pan sauce made from pantry staples.
I halved the recipe for the two of us and substituted granulated garlic for fresh. Two bone-in breasts were seasoned with kosher salt under the skin, which I pricked to help render the fat before lightly spraying with oil. I started them skin side down on the stovetop until well browned, then flipped and finished them in a 325° oven to 160° internal temperature.
After removing the chicken, I returned the skillet to the heat and cooked the juices until they formed a dark fond. Butter and granulated garlic went in, followed by orange zest and thyme. Once fragrant, I stirred in orange juice and whole-grain mustard. Off heat, I added another strip of zest and a few fresh thyme sprigs. The chicken was removed from the bones, sliced, and served with the sauce. Total time was just under an hour.
The dish lived up to expectations. The chicken was tender and the sauce a nice complement, though the mustard was the dominant flavor. Halving the recipe gave us dinner for two nights. I’d make it again—perhaps trying the lime-hoisin or pineapple-cilantro variations next time.
