November 2026
Recipe from Cook's Illustrated, May 2021
I can’t quite remember where I recently heard a mention of banana muffins, but it sent me searching for a recipe so I could try them. I like to alternate between cereal and homemade baked goods for breakfast, and since I had run out of baked options—and was growing tired of eating cereal every single morning—the timing felt right. I love classic banana bread, so I hoped these muffins might offer the same comfort in a format that’s faster to bake and easier to store and grab on the go.
The process itself was straightforward. I started by whisking together all-purpose flour, baking powder, baking soda, and salt in a bowl, then carefully toasted chopped walnuts in the microwave. Next, I peeled and mashed enough ripe bananas to yield about two cups, whisking them together with sugar, eggs, oil, and vanilla extract. After whisking the dry ingredients into the banana mixture and stirring in the cooled, toasted walnuts, I portioned the batter into 12 oiled muffin cups and finished the tops with a sprinkle of sugar. They baked at 425°F until a toothpick inserted into the center came out clean—bringing total active and bake time, excluding cooling, to just under an hour.
So, how did they turn out? Overall, the muffins were good and held up well in the freezer, though thawing softened the sugar topping so it lost the sweet crunch it had fresh out of the oven. The crumb had a great texture, with the toasted walnuts adding just the right amount of bite. My biggest disappointment, however, was the surprisingly muted banana flavor. Even though my bananas were darkly speckled, they probably weren't quite overripe enough to pack a punch.While they were a nice change of pace from cereal, these muffins probably won’t be replacing classic banana bread in my breakfast rotation anytime soon.

.png)