October 2026
Recipe from Cook's Illustrated, November 2026
Shepherd’s Pie—or Cottage Pie, when made with beef—is a staple in our house. It’s the ultimate hearty comfort food for cold, dark winter days, traditionally built on a rich ground beef filling and a classic mashed potato topping. Naturally, I was intrigued when I came across a new recipe that swapped in sweet potatoes for the topping and used traditional ground lamb for the filling.
I made a few minor tweaks to the published recipe based on what I had on hand and our personal tastes. The recipe calls for 1½ pounds of ground lamb; I only had 1 pound of ground New Zealand lamb, so I supplemented it with 9 ounces of ground beef to round out the protein. I also omitted the nutmeg (since my wife isn't a fan) and ended up using a few ounces more sweet potato than called for.
To start, I microwaved the sweet potatoes until tender—this took close to 10 minutes, which gave me plenty of time to prep most of the other ingredients. Once the potatoes cooled, I scooped out the flesh, discarded the skins, and mashed it with half-and-half, melted butter, and salt.
Next, I heated vegetable oil in a 10-inch skillet and browned the ground meats with paprika, cardamom, black pepper, and salt until no longer pink. After transferring the meat to a bowl, I cooked the onions and carrots in the same skillet until softened, then stirred in tomato paste, garlic, and fresh thyme until fragrant. From there, I added beef broth, cornstarch, and the cooked meat back into the pan, brought it to a boil, and let it simmer until the carrots were tender and the sauce had thickened. Off the heat, I stirred in peas and Worcestershire sauce. Finally, I spread a smooth layer of the sweet potato mash over the filling, dragged a fork across the top to create ridges, and broiled it until lightly browned. All told, it took about 90 minutes and yielded four generous dinners for the two of us.
We both really enjoyed this take on Shepherd's Pie. It feels noticeably lighter than the traditional version, largely thanks to the natural sweetness of the potato topping. Having never cooked with ground lamb before, I was also surprised to find it didn't have the strong, gamey flavor I usually associate with lamb. While we'll probably save the heavier beef-and-russet version for the dead of winter, this lighter, brighter spin is one we’ll gladly make again during warmer weather.
.png)