Recipe Notes: Pizza Al Taglio with Arugula and Fresh Mozzarella

18 August 2019

Recipe from Cook's Illustrated, March 2019.

I have not made many pizzas from scratch. After reading the article in the recent Cook's Illustrated I knew that I wanted to make this one. It is unlike pizza as we think of it. It's distinguishing feature is a an airy, chewy crust that is crisp on both top and bottom, burnished with a thin layer of sauce. Rather than round it is baked on a sheet pan and then cut up to be eaten. Al taglio translates to "when cut" in English.

The dough was made a day ahead of time. The long, cold fermentation built both structure and flavor. Bread flour and yeast were whisked together. Water and extra-virgin olive oil (EVOO) were stirred into the dry ingredients and the shaggy dough was left to sit for 10 minutes. Salt was then stirred into the dough and it rested for another 20 minutes. The kneading method consisted of folding the dough onto itself in the bowl, then turning the bowl and repeating six times. The dough rested and the folding/turning process was repeated followed by another rest. It was then placed in an oiled baking pan, covered, and put into the refrigerator for 25 hours. The preparation process took about 80 minutes.

The next day sauce was made by combining canned tomatoes, extra-virgin olive oil, anchovy paste (the recipe specified fillets, I guesstimated a substitution of paste), dried oregano, table salt, and red pepper flakes in a blender. The dough was removed from the refrigerator, drizzled with EVOO, and inverted onto a rimmed baking sheet. After stretching the dough to the edges of the baking sheet it was covered and left to rise. A small amount of the sauce, just ½ cup, was distributed over the dough then covered with a thin layer of EVOO. The pizza (with no toppings!) was baked in a 450° oven for about 20 minutes. It was cut into squares and topped with arugula that had been dressed with EVOO, some fresh mozzarella, and parmesan cheese. Total time to prepare the pizza on day 2 was 110 minutes.

I need to make pizza more often because this was great! The star was the crust which was crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, with a pleasing complex flavor. The sauce provided some subtle background notes and this was all complemented by the fresh greens and creamy cheeses. As leftovers it was still good as the toppings were added fresh. However, and this was no surprise, it did not have the great crusty texture of the fresh pizza. The biggest criticism I have is that it makes too much for just the two of us. This leads to having leftovers which lack the impact of the freshly baked pizza. The recipe includes two other suggestions for toppings that would be fun to try. Diane wanted the cheese to be melted and at least one of these variations has that.